Riley, a plus-size girl, has a secret crush on hockey team captain Connor. Because of her low self-esteem, she uses her roommate Chloe’s photo to date him online. What she doesn’t know is that Connor has long recognized her as the girl who protected him in childhood and has been quietly playing along all this time. After Riley becomes the hockey team’s assistant, Connor is gentle and flirtatious with her in real life and sweet and chatty with her online. Finally, Riley gathers the courage to meet Connor, only to find that Chloe has gotten there first. Her insecurity makes Riley pull away from Connor. At last, Connor confesses the truth: he knew it was her all along and has been waiting for her to come to him as her true self. The two clear up the misunderstanding and end up together.