Novelist Noelle lies to her mother that she has a boyfriend and rents one—Jack, the man who once mocked her at a café. They sign a contract and fake a relationship. Her cousin Chloe and aunt Vivian doubt him, but when Jack is revealed as a conglomerate chairman's son, the family is stunned. Chloe demands they kiss to prove it; Jack does, and real feelings begin. A plagiarism scandal hits; Jack's lawyers help Noelle prove her innocence, while Chloe leaks the "fake boyfriend" story online and is forced to confess. Jack's fiancée Serena is exposed, but he promises to break the engagement. Jack disappears; when he returns, he confesses he's the reader who wrote to Noelle years ago. On Christmas Eve, Jack arrives with his parents and a giant Christmas tree exactly like the one in Noelle's novel, confessing his love. Noelle confesses too—and they truly become a couple. The story ends with the family reunited for Christmas.