To prevent her family fortune from falling into the hands of her father's mistress, the blind Christine arranges to conceive a child via a sperm donor—a college student named Alex—but ends up sleeping with Nathan, an undercover mobster, by mistake. The next day, she meets her father's mistress for the first time, only to discover the "woman" is actually a man—and none other than Nathan, the very man she had slept with the night before! Blind and unaware of the truth, Christine clashes fiercely with Nathan by day, yet sheds her defenses at night, snuggling into the arms of "Alex" to vent about that infuriating man! Nathan finds himself in a bind, yet secretly enjoys the situation. Just as genuine feelings begin to develop on both sides, however, the real Alex appears—and the "game of deception" Nathan orchestrated can no longer be kept under wraps...